Skip to main content

Online Teaching's Disconnect

Today's LA Times has an op-ed by John Villasenor of UCLA about online vs. face-to-face teaching. I think he offers a pretty standard view of instruction, and this paragraph illustrates his key point that the in-person, classroom experience is what is special about teaching:

A course is also made effective by the unscripted interactions that occur as students gather before and after the class, and by the simple fact that the physical act of getting to class requires at least some investment of time and energy. In short, attending a well-run class in person is immersive and engaging in a way that far exceeds anything that consumer technology can possibly hope to deliver now or in the foreseeable future.


Oddly enough, the article is accompanied by a photo of students in a chemistry lecture at UCLA in what appears to be a very large auditorium. To me, this instructional format is not one that offers the type of engaging and interactive learning experience that I enjoyed as a student or that Professor Villasenor describes in his essay. Large lectures, which I experienced both as a student and instructor, seemed to me a pragmatic solution to the problem of how to provide instruction to a very large group of people at the same time, even if the same time part of it wasn't essential. Large lectures typically don't offer much interaction (the use of clickers may be changing this to a degree) because it's not practical when there are 150 or 300 or 500 students in the classroom for a 50 minute class period. Classes like this usually have a separate discussion section where students can interact with a teaching assistant in a smaller classroom. Why not just record the lectures, make them available to students, and allow more time for the smaller group meetings? 


Professor Villasenor does a good job of highlighting the advantages of online classes for those students who can't be on campus for the traditional classes. There seems to be an unstated assumption in his essay that online and face-to-face teaching should be similar. I think we know from experience that an online instructor who doesn't make adjustments when moving from face-to-face to online won't be successful. Just as instruction in a 15 student seminar is going to be different than in a 500 student lecture hall, online teaching methods also have to be adjusted to suit the learning environment. 


Ironically, his emphasis on "showing up" in the face-t0-face classroom:


But policymakers, university teachers and administrators should acknowledge that scientific studies and budget pressures notwithstanding, something is lost when the classroom experience becomes virtual. As we strive to educate our university students in an increasingly competitive global economic climate, among the many costly and complex measures that are on the table for improving their educational experience, here's one that is refreshingly simple: Show up.
is the primary principle I emphasize when working with online instructors. If you aren't present in the online classroom, you aren't teaching. Instructor presence is different online, but it's still what differentiates good teaching from just going through the motions. In that regard, maybe face-to-face and online teaching are not that different, but the methods used to reach similar learning goals shouldn't be the same.

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Blackboard Podcasts

I've been searching for podcasts about Blackboard and have come across a few. Some are too site-specific while others could use a little more polish before I would recommend them to others. However, one podcast I did find to be useful and high quality is Teaching with Blackboard by Jason Rhode at Northern Illinois University. Episode 5, posted last week, discusses how to incorporate RSS feeds into Blackboard using Feed2JS , a website and tool for converting an RSS feed to JavaScript which can be copied and pasted into your Blackboard course. This gives you a relatively easy way to add dynamic content to a course. For many instructors, RSS may be a foreign language, but I think if you listen to the five minute podcast, you will learn enough to get the idea. If you want more, Jason's previous podcast covers RSS and podcasting in more detail.
2 comments
Read more

QuickSource Guides to Blackboard

The Resource Network in Harrisonburg, Virginia, publishes fold out guides to various software applications like MS Office, WordPerfect, Adobe Acrobat and more. They have student and instructor guides to BlackBoard for $4.00 each. Prices are lower if you buy in bulk. I got mine yesterday and they look nice and are easy to read. Each one covers the important things you need to know to use Blackboard as a student or instructor. They are also available through Amazon.com for $4.95 each.
Post a Comment
Read more

Tracking in Moodle forums

Tracking is a feature in Moodle forums which will highlight unread forum messages so you can easily see what is new to you. You can turn tracking on and off for individual forums, but in order to use it, you must first turn it on in your profile. Instructors have the option of turning tracking on or off or making it optional for each forum they create in a course. This means if your instructor turns off tracking, you won't be able to track posts in a forum. The default setting is optional, so each student can decide whether or not to track posts. If you turn on tracking for a forum and you are also subscribed to that forum (receiving copies of posts via email), you will notice that posts you've been emailed will be marked as read once you return to the forum in Moodle. There is no communication between the email message and Moodle –– as long as you are sent the post via email, Moodle will mark it as read. If you aren't going to read forum posts via email, you may want to tu...
Post a Comment
Read more