Skip to main content

Comparing face to face and online teaching evaluations

Comparing face to face with online teaching is often the first thing people think of when they want to know if online teaching and learning is any good (as if there was some uniformity across courses and the medium was somehow more important than the instructor). My feeling is that they are two different things and it's tough to make valid comparisons, but it's still useful to try, in some cases. In the current issue of The Internet and Higher Education, Kelly, Ponton and Rovai write about their effort to understand how student evaluations of teaching differ between face to face and online courses. Their conclusion is that:
Face-to-face students tended to consider the instructor more important than online students, and they wanted their instructor to be of good character and be knowledgeable in the content; however, for online students, the course was more important than the instructor where the course organization and instructional materials were especially important. Therefore, online course design should provide a clear guide through the learning activities (Laurillard et al., 2000; Palloff & Pratt, 2001; Priest, 2000). Also, instructors should carefully select the instructional materials because the online instructor is generally no longer considered the repository of information (Sherry & Wilson, 1997). Students still need the instructor, but significant learning will occur through learner–content interaction and learner–learner interaction.

Teaching online really does expose the instructional design of a course more than face to face teaching because it's so important and so much more obvious. There's no fallback where everyone shows up for the same 3 hours a week and the instructor lectures. This is also why teaching online can influence how people teach face to face, and why someone who is inflexible in terms of instruction will likely have a hard time teaching online.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Blackboard Podcasts

I've been searching for podcasts about Blackboard and have come across a few. Some are too site-specific while others could use a little more polish before I would recommend them to others. However, one podcast I did find to be useful and high quality is Teaching with Blackboard by Jason Rhode at Northern Illinois University. Episode 5, posted last week, discusses how to incorporate RSS feeds into Blackboard using Feed2JS , a website and tool for converting an RSS feed to JavaScript which can be copied and pasted into your Blackboard course. This gives you a relatively easy way to add dynamic content to a course. For many instructors, RSS may be a foreign language, but I think if you listen to the five minute podcast, you will learn enough to get the idea. If you want more, Jason's previous podcast covers RSS and podcasting in more detail.

QuickSource Guides to Blackboard

The Resource Network in Harrisonburg, Virginia, publishes fold out guides to various software applications like MS Office, WordPerfect, Adobe Acrobat and more. They have student and instructor guides to BlackBoard for $4.00 each. Prices are lower if you buy in bulk. I got mine yesterday and they look nice and are easy to read. Each one covers the important things you need to know to use Blackboard as a student or instructor. They are also available through Amazon.com for $4.95 each.

Tracking in Moodle forums

Tracking is a feature in Moodle forums which will highlight unread forum messages so you can easily see what is new to you. You can turn tracking on and off for individual forums, but in order to use it, you must first turn it on in your profile. Instructors have the option of turning tracking on or off or making it optional for each forum they create in a course. This means if your instructor turns off tracking, you won't be able to track posts in a forum. The default setting is optional, so each student can decide whether or not to track posts. If you turn on tracking for a forum and you are also subscribed to that forum (receiving copies of posts via email), you will notice that posts you've been emailed will be marked as read once you return to the forum in Moodle. There is no communication between the email message and Moodle –– as long as you are sent the post via email, Moodle will mark it as read. If you aren't going to read forum posts via email, you may want to tu...